Now that Bones has actually concluded its 12-seaboy run, it"s hard to imagine a time once Dr. Temperance "Bones" Brennan (Emily Deschanel) and provided John Wilkes Booth descendent FBI Special Agent Seeley Booth (David Boreanaz) weren"t together. But even the most ardent "Semperance" (or "B-Squared," depending on who you ask) shipper can"t deny that both characters had actually other romances in their previous. While Bones largely stuck to casual dates or friends-with-benefits kind instances, Booth is even more of a romantic. In fact, he came incredibly cshed to marrying another woman during the show"s sixth seaboy.

You are watching: Booth and hannah break up scene

After a failed start to what would go on to be a successful relationship with Bones, Booth meets journalist Hannah Burley (Katheryn Winnick, in a stunningly divergent pre-Vikings role) while briefly deployed in Afghanistan. The 2 waste no time progressing their relationship, with Hannah moving right into Booth"s apartment in Washington, D.C. after she retransforms from the Center East. Although Booth isn"t in denial that he still harbors feelings for Bones, he sees Hannah as his future.

On the seakid 6 episode "The Dareadversary in the Mold," Booth takes a huge step toward moving on from his facility feelings for his frifinish and also colleague and committing himself to a new womale. He proposes to Hannah ... but unfortunately finds out the difficult method that Hannah is "simply not the marrying type."

The rejection was heartbreaking for Booth and also any kind of viewers who wanted to watch him spreview his wings and also date someone various other than Bones. But it"s what happens following that had some fans unable to watch.

Booth couldn"t have picked a more picturesque area for his proposal: appropriate alengthy the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool. When Hannah rejects him and also then walks amethod, Booth looks out over the water in a moment of reflection, and then takes the ring he was providing her and chucks it right into the pool.

Reddit fan u/NotoriousB_i_queen had actually a tough time accepting Booth"s hasty ring toss. They began a threview succinctly and also calmly titled, "YEARS after it happened, eexceptionally single time I check out it I desire to CRY. SEELEY BOOTH WHY WOULD YOU THROW AN ENGAGEMENT RING THAT WAS THAT EXPENSIVE INTO A LAKE???? SHE SAID NO I GET IT BUT YOU COULD HAVE RESOLD IT AND GOT YOUR MONEY BACK."

Fellow Bones fans thought some points were made. Redditor u/MsTerrell confessed that the scene was too a lot for them to take, writing, "I commonly rapid forward or walk out of the room every single time."

Many customers thought Booth was simply piling on more misery for himself by throwing hundreds of dollars away. User u/Ivehearditbothwaysss discussed that the whole point was specifically painful considering exactly how a lot " complains about his salary."

Alternatively, Redditor u/DingoD3 construed wright here Booth was coming from: "In that minute, in that burst of pain, you"re not thinking around money." However, also they weren"t without critique. They followed that empathetic statement through, "He was an idiot to buy it in the first location. Hannah was exceptionally clear that she was not the marrying kind."

In the finish, user u/AnotherCurrency had the ability to see the cinematic worth of the action: " guess that the scene where Booth pawns the ring for some cash doesn"t have actually the same emotional intensity as Booth throwing the ring right into the river."

Fans clearly had actually some solid feelings about Booth"s decision to ditch the engagement ring he bought for Hannah, however exactly how a lot of that is around the ring, and also just how much is around the finish of "Boannah"? The answer is surprisingly even more nuanced than meant.

See more: How It Feels To Be Colored Me Questions And Answers, How It Feels To Be Colored Me, Zora Neale Hurston

Confirmed B&B diehard u/Petrizzle responded to a threview around Hannah by confessing, "I execute have to admit that if Booth had to be via someone various other than Bones, Hannah would certainly not have been a bad alternative."

Reddit user u/SpiderSmoothie bravely outed themselves as an anti-Semperance fan by saying, "I believed and Booth were great together. I"m not a fan of the Booth/Bones pairing, tbh. Hannah was such a great character."

On the flip side, user u/Strict-Teaching was unababurned in their dismissal of anything gaining in the means of Booth and Bones ending up together. Regarding Hannah, they admitted, "I kind of hated her also even though tright here was nopoint super unlikable about her, maybe that"s why: she seems too perfect."

Still, despite not outappropriate hating Hannah, fans weren"t specifically crying out in anguish at the end of her and also Booth"s relationship, and numerous cited an incapacity to gain over the feeling that she was constantly expected to be nopoint more than an obstacle for B-Squared. In one more threview, user u/Flibberdejibbet posited that Booth can not be too heartbroken about the breakup, either: "I think sabotaged the partnership subconsciously on purpose. They hadn"t even been together for a year, she"d made it plenty clear she wasn"t the marrying kind, and he still proposed!? He absolutely was searching for a method out."

It could not be too late to gain some diving gear and also uncover that ring! Keep an eye out for that canceled Bones spin-off while you"re down there.