Cynthia Cooper was a true corpoprice whistleblower. She becamerenowned, not by choice, however because of the WorldCom financial statementfraud valued at $11 billion. She was the Vice President of InternalAudit at WorldCom, a place that was not easily acquired. She almostsingle-handedly created the internal audit department at WorldCom, andher book Extraplain Circumstances: The Journey of a Corpoprice Whistleblower
details the battle to get monitoring to take inner audit seriously.

You are watching: Extraordinary circumstances the journey of a corporate whistleblower

Things started going wrong at WorldCom very early on. The firm wenton an acquisition spree, and also the merging of many kind of small companies,supervisors, and also accounting devices was a disaster waiting to occur.Cynthia claims that WorldCom was a lot better at gaining carriers thanintegrating them, and that is clear.

From an audit perspective, it was alongside impossible to createa appropriately controlled system. Tright here were also many little systems beingpieced together, and also it was easy for numbers and authorizations to getlost in the shuffle. This battle is well-documented by Cynthia, whono doubt painstakingly researched the various acquisitions in order togive such a finish history.

Attimes the book appears to get a tiny off-topic as Cynthia goes througheach player’s background briefly. Honestly, that information isn’treally appropriate to the story and, while it was probably intfinished tomake these personalities relatable human beings, it really simply serves tomake the book longer than essential. It prolongs the procedure of gettingto the genuine heart of the story.

I was attracted right into the parts detailing the background of Bernie Ebbersand his early entrepreneurial endeavors. I don’t think Cynthia cameideal out and said that Ebbers wasn’t equipped to run WorldCom, butthat’s precisely just how it appears as soon as you’re done analysis.

Wright here this book is so excellent is in detailing the fraud and also just how itoccurred. I don’t think the majority of consumers know exactly how and also wbelow WorldCom’sfraud started: all in the “line prices.” You don’t require an accountingbackground to understand the details of the fraud as soon as Cynthia explaindisplay points went dvery own. Incomes were as well low and also management was, quitesimply, in search of a area to reduce expenses.

When management realized they were paying too a lot for capacity thatthey weren’t selling to customers, it ended up being clear. Take some of those“line costs” and capitalize them, which basically quantities to movingthem off the profit and loss statement (decreasing prices andraising profits) and onto the balance sheet (enhancing assets).

WorldCom moved those line costs right into something that the executivesdubbed “prephelp capacity.” The company’s financials instantly lookedmuch better, and also CFO Scott Sullivan found that this was an easy method torehabilitate the financial statements each quarter. Wall Street wantedlots of growth, and also that’s exactly what the executives delivered by thetime the fraudulent accounting entries were completed.

Yet the process of uncovering this fraud, as Cynthia and also her teamwould shortly discover out, was grueling. Their investigation right into theaudit shenanigans was lengthy because the accountancy entries behindthis manipulation of the financial statements were complex. Hundreds ofentries were made to a variety of accounts in order to confuse anyonewho could later on look at them. And the investigation was hard becausemonitoring didn’t desire Cynthia and her human being looking right into the entries,for apparent factors.

After the fraud became clear to Cynthia and also her team, tright here was along fight over whether something should or could be done about it.Scott Sullivan was determined to discover an accountancy dominion to justify thefraudulent bookkeeping entries. It is no surpclimb that there is not anaudit dominion that backs up what was done, bereason it wasn’t donethrough the accounting rules in mind. It was done via just Wall Street inmind.

And WorldCom’s audit committee wasn’t entirely behind the internalauditors’ investigation or outcomes. The audit committee need to be theindependent team of individuals to whom an employee deserve to voice concernsand be taken seriously. Yet Cynthia didn’t seem to be offered as muchconsideration as she should have actually been, and she relates this strugglenicely in the book.

The story of the investigation concerns life with Cynthia’swords. I discovered myself drawn into the story, and I could feel myselfsitting tbelow as the inner auditors were going via enattempt afterenattempt, constantly watching their backs because the executives didn’t wantthem investigating.

Lots of clichés and also heartwarming stories of family members interactions arewoven right into the book. Aacquire, these things aren’t really all thatpertinent to the story and simply offered a distractivity from thecompany at hand: the collapse of WorldCom.

These minor objections don’t take ameans from the book overall. Itis a comprehensive account of what occurred, and also digs a lot deeper into theWorldCom fraud than I ever meant. The detail behind exactly how the fraudemerged is told in a fascinating manner, and I found myself able tophoto WorldCom executives sitting roughly and comparing the company’sfinancial outcomes to the expectations of Wall surface Street … and makingfraudulent accountancy entries to fulfill those expectations.

See more: Here'S Kanye West Audition For American Idol ' Audition

Congratulations, Cynthia, on a successful initially book. And manythanks for being willing to stand up for the fact and fight to exposethe WorldCom fraud.