What is the distinction in between the above adverbial modifier of location and "IN the picture" if any?

In "Gamings for Vocabulary Practice" by Felicity O"Dsteustatiushistory.org and also Katie Head (Cambridge,2003) I have actually come across this phrase more than once analysis the guidelines for running tasks, e.g. "Student B preoften tends to be the perkid ON the picture".

You are watching: On the picture or in the picture


*

The normal thing is "in the picture" as

In the picture we view Edinburgh Castle.

In English a snapshot is viewed as a space; and also a landscape, in fact, depicts a space and subsequently you say: "In the image we view a hilly countryside with a river and also green meadows through sheep and in the background tright here is a tiny village."

In other languperiods a picture or paint may be viewed not as area, yet as an area, and also "on the picture" is used in German.


*

*

When describing the civilization or things which appear in a picture, we usage "in".

If you were to usage the expression "on the picture", it would many likely be to define somepoint that was not component of the picture originally, however is now on it.

"Your coffee cup is sitting on the picture!""I left out the crayons, and also my toddler drew on the photo you left. So sorry!"

ETA: In North Amerihave the right to English, the example you offered would certainly be ungrammatical. I see the book was publimelted in England also, though. Perhaps it is thought about an acceptable building there.


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Oct 28 "14 at 16:24
answered Oct 28 "14 at 12:50
*

michsteustatiushistory.orgemichsteustatiushistory.orge
2,22999 silver badges1313 bronze badges
4
Add a comment |
5
I have never heard the phrase "on the picture" to mean "among the things|persons captured by the cam here". For that interpretation, it is always "in the picture".

Who is this perchild in the picture?

One deserve to say "shown on the picture" to expect "which shows up in this image".

Point to the strange expansion of foliage, shown on this image, which you think to be the gangster"s camouflaged hideout.

One can create an essay around a painting or photograph or movie, and say that one was creating an essay "on the picture", i.e. "around the picture".


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
edited Oct 28 "14 at 13:22
answered Oct 28 "14 at 12:21
*

TᴚoɯɐuoTᴚoɯɐuo
118k77 gold badges9494 silver badges194194 bronze badges
4
Add a comment |
2
This is the very same in British English as in North Amerideserve to English, so the example sentence is ungrammatical - the explanation given by michsteustatiushistory.orge applies equally to both.

As a indigenous speaker, I would certainly assume that this is not strictly a grammatical error (meaning the writer thought it was correct), yet a typographical one (definition the writer did not notice their mistake). Because you mention seeing it more than once I would suspect a copy/pasting error.

(It might seem odd for this to be missed by the editor, yet these things perform occur.)


Share
Improve this answer
Follow
answered Oct 28 "14 at 16:55
NyeNye
12733 bronze badges
Add a comment |
2
Unit 8 Describing peoplethe instructions reads

Warm-up

1 Give each pair of students an envelope containing a collection of photo cards and ask them to spreview them out in front of them. Choose a snapshot and pretend to be the perkid on the picture. Describe yourself in 5 sentences without discussing your name. E.g. I have fair hair, not dark hair. I am a woman. My hair is brief, not long. I am wearing __ , and so on. After 5 sentences, ask students to guess who the person is.

<...>

Key activity

Give each student an envelope containing a collection of photo cards. Students then play in their pairs. Student A puts all their photos face up on the table. Tsteustatiushistory.org Student B to choose one photo from their very own envelope and also look at it without mirroring it to Student A. Student B pretends to be the person on the photo.

See more: What Does All Hail The King Mean Ing Of "Hail To The King", All Hail King Jesus

The expression “... on the picture” as it is used is grammatical in its conmessage. It is short for on the picture card. The author has omitted card from the sentence because it was pointed out in the instructions: a set of image cards

Tbelow are various other instances as soon as making use of on with picture, or image would fit in a teaching environment.

Focus students" attention on the image.Student B should focus on the photo, and explain it to their companion.Student A sticks the pets wright here they want on the photo.Student B secretly draws a residence on the image. (Although "in the picture" would be even more idiomatic)