To eexceptionally marketing executive, the need and also worth of test marketing are regularly murky problems. The trouble is partly that new commodities aren’t arisen and put via their paces in a organized sufficient way to let marketing men understand when a test industry is really in order. Compounding this obstacle is that the purposes of <…>

To eextremely marketing executive, the requirement and value of test marketing are regularly murky issues. The problem is partly that new products aren’t arisen and put through their paces in a systematic sufficient method to let marketing males understand as soon as a test sector is really in order. Compounding this obstacle is that the goals of <…>


To eincredibly marketing executive, the necessity and value of test marketing are frequently murky worries. The difficulty is partly that brand-new commodities aren’t developed and put via their paces in a systematic sufficient means to let marketing males understand once a test industry is really in order. Compounding this obstacle is that the goals of <…>


To eextremely marketing executive, the requirement and worth of test marketing are regularly murky issues. The problem is partly that brand-new commodities aren’t occurred and also put via their paces in a organized enough method to let marketing guys understand as soon as a test sector is really in order. Compounding this difficulty is that the objectives of test marketing are periodically unclear and also that the information, as soon as gathered, is often imeffectively provided. This post is an effort to lay bare the bones of the issue. Beginning through an introduction of sound brand-new product development, it clarifies as soon as a test industry have to be done, what its aims must be, and to what supplies it should be put. Relying for many type of of their judgments on quoted first-person intersee material via marketing executives, the authors end up with a postmanuscript on exactly how technological invention deserve to help in test marketing.

You are watching: One disadvantage of test marketing a new product is that

The executive should weigh a myriad of information as he decides whether to go with a brand-new product. To assist him in his decision, he may consider test marketing to gather yet more information.

For the executive contemplating test marketing, we intfinish to emphasis first on 3 strategic questions:

When need to you conduct a test market? What deserve to you learn from a test market? How need to you use information from a test market?

We will certainly then check out current advancements in new product research—specifically, the usage of simulation models and test industries in the laboratory atmosphere.

The inquiries and answers that follow reflect test marketing experiences we gathered from 31 marketing study executives that had actually been connected in hundreds of brand-new product introductions. (See the sidebar “Commentators” for the list of interviewees.) These assets consisted of packaged grocery items, health-care assets, and consumer durables. The executives represent 3 orientations towards test markets—the manufacturer, the heralding firm, and also the marketing study provided.


Alvin A. Achenbaum, Principal, Canter & Achenbaum, Inc., New York

Valentine Appel, President, W.R. Simmons Company, New York

Joel P. Baumwoll, Senior Vice President, Research and Planning, J. Wchange Thompchild Company type of

Henry J. Claycamp, Vice President, Corpoprice Marketing, International Harvester Company, Chicearlier

Theodore F. Dunn, Senior Vice President, Director of Research Services, Benton & Bowles, New York

Robert J. Eggert, Staff Vice President, Economics and also Marketing Research, RCA Corporation, New York

Gerald J. Eskin, Associate Professor of Business Administration, University of Iowa, Iowa City

R. Stephen Fountaine, Director of Marketing Research, Philip Morris, New York

Lawrence D. Gibchild, Director of Marketing Research, General Mills, Inc., Minneapolis

Paul F. Hase, Vice President, Research 100, Princeton, New Jersey

Calvin Hodock, Vice President, Consumer Research, Carter Wallace, Inc., New York

Alfred A. Kuehn, President, Market Science Associates, New York

Robert J. Lavidge, President, Elrick & Lavidge, Inc., Chicago

Philip Levine, Senior Vice President, Director of Research, Ogilvy & Mather, New York

Lawrence M. Light, Research Director, Senior Vice President, BBD&O, New York

Benjamin Lipstein, Senior Vice President, Director of Research, SSC&B, New York

Kenneth Longguy, President, Benboy & Benchild, Inc., Princeton, New Jersey

Rictough Lysaker, Senior Vice President, Audits & Surveys, New York

John McMennamin, Vice President, Research and New Products Director, Norton Simon Communications, New York

Joseph Nearby, Director of Market Planning, McCall’s Patterns, New York

Sheldon Newmale, Director of Marketing Research, Chesebrough-Pond’s, Inc., Greenwich, Connecticut

Robert Olins, Vice President and Director of Research, Young & Rubicam, Chicearlier

Alvin Ossip, Associate Director Marketing Research Department, General Foods Corporation, White Plains, New York

Arthur S. Pearchild, Director of Marketing Services, Clairol, Inc., New York

Vincent Petrilli, Marketing Consultant, Chicback

Fred Posner, Associate Director, Marketing Research Department, General Foods Corporation, White Plains, New York

Robert W. Pratt, Jr., Manager, Firm Research and also Forecasting Operation, Major Appliance Business Group, General Electric Company

William Saint, Manager, Sales Forecasting and also Sales Research, Chesebrough-Pond’s, Inc., Greenwich

Raymond E. Schucker, Marketing Research, Consultant, Minneapolis

Michael von Gonten, Senior Vice President, Research Equipment, Inc., Evansville, Indiana

William Weilbacher, Vice Chairmale, Dancer Fitzgerald Sample, Inc., New York

Whether to test sector is a damage between collecting even more information, at considerable straight and indirect cost, to mitigate uncertainty, and introducing the product automatically to make money. As Posner points out, “Every month in test implies offering up sales if the product turns out to be successful.”

The straight prices of test marketing encompass a pilot plant to make the product, commercials, an advertising company because media are not billed, point-of-sale material produced in small amounts, greater media prices because of low quantities, couponing, sampling, and also higher profession allowances to attain circulation. For instance, the expense for a typical two-city test industry in 1975 was $250,000. Four tests were compelled to test 2 levels of ad weight. This expected a market testing expense of $500,000.

But there are additionally instraight expenses. Tbelow is, for instance, the cost of revealing a brand-new product idea to a challenger. If he is much better organized for brand-new product introductions, he deserve to beat you to the market. It is hard to estimate the expense of being second in the market, however marketing endure suggests that it means a lower industry share and also better promotional costs.

Anvarious other instraight expense is that of exposure. “If you are cultivating a household brand also, you are exposing the name of your firm and also the brand also,” Clay-camp reminds.

“If you get a reputation for battle, you might have trouble acquiring circulation the following time, or in enlisting the enthusiasm of the sales pressure,” observes Kuehn. It is impossible to estimate these exposure expenses.

Diversion of employee time and tasks is an internal, out-of-pocket price that is hardly ever quantified when the expense of test markets is estimated. “The inner costs for test marketing are tremendous. They divert monitoring attention and manpower from other tasks,” McMennamin advises.

Adds Newman, “Sales administration objects to as well many kind of test industries bereason they take away from sales activities.”

These high direct and indirect expenses of test marketing administer a solid inspiration for postponing the decision to test market until the marketing executive feels confident he has actually the 3 fundamental facets of the ideal product breakthrough plan secure: a effective product, a competitive marketing strategy, and a remarkable communication plan. Many kind of researchers feel that test marketing need to be the last check before rolling the product out into nationwide circulation. “I would certainly say the batting average should be somewbelow between 65% and also 75%,” Pearboy calculates.

Light maintains that “when you go into test market, you’ve made the decision to go. The test sector deserve to of course change your plans by offering you a no-go. But in the absence of negative results, you continue.”

The rising prices of test markets have actually led researchers to usage less expensive techniques to kill a product or heralding campaign at an early stage in the process of new product breakthrough. “You definitely don’t want to use a test sector to learn something that you could have learned earlier—test marketing is much also expensive,” Longman insists.

Implicit in the comments of our marketing executives is a well-articulated new product advancement process. It is to this process that the executives tacitly appeal as soon as they make their judgments on the costs of test marketing.

A conceptualization of this process appears in the exhibit, “An Idealized Process For New Product Growth.” Here we can check out how a product and also a communication plan need to be refined prior to test marketing.


Exhilittle bit An Idealized Process For New Product Development


When Should You Conduct a Test Market?

The initially step in the new product sequence is an identification of opportunities—requirements not being met adequately by products that are presently obtainable. This phase of research study generally uses qualitative methods obtained from social psychology. One approach frequently offered is the focus-team or group-depth interwatch. This is a two-hour conversation in which 8 to 12 persons are asked to explain their experiences through present commodities or to recount just how they manage certain difficulties.

For instance, a pharmaceutical firm might ask a team of young mothers just how they treat a child’s cold. Mothers’ perceptions of the toughness and weaknesses of available products will certainly involved light during these discussions. Such interviews carry out principles for new products or for expansion of existing assets. These concepts are actually hypotheses that have the right to then be tested with even more quantitative approaches such as the survey.

Elimination of all yet a couple of of the ideas is normally a subjective procedure. It may be based on the endure of marketing executives, the politics of the agency, or the executives’ definition of their service and also its capacity. (Capacity need to be defined to include not only manufacturing and also financial capabilities, however additionally executives’ capability to run in the industry of the proposed product.)

The number of product ideas ultimately favored relies on the sources of the company and its strategy for brand-new assets. Given restricted resources, need to a agency select only one or two ideas and also spfinish a lot of of its sources on emerging communication plans, or must it retain 4 or 5 product concepts and test just a couple of interaction plans for each one? The answer to this question need to reflect the history and strengths of the company. If most of its resources are in product R&D, it will most likely experiment more through ideas than if its stamina is in marketing and also communications.

The following step in our ideal new product breakthrough is producing a preliminary profit plan that estimates the length of the payout. Based largely on estimates by knowledgeable marketing executives, this profit setup deserve to get rid of product candidates that execute not reach the minimum payout period set by administration.

(Each stage in the exhilittle bit relocations management estimates through data, thereby reducing the selection of uncertainty in estimating the profit plan.)

The facility section of the exhilittle has actually three columns—product breakthrough, strategy advancement, and also communication advancement. These columns emphasize an extremely necessary point: the actions included in them are taken concurrently, not serially. Advertising development, for instance, does not wait till a product is polished before starting its occupational, yet starts immediately on the difficulty of connecting the idea reflected in the item.

Anticipated availability of a product in part determines the approaches for its trial and error. For instance, a minimum of facilities may be compelled to produce actual commodities for trial and error a product expansion such as the enhancement of a lemon flavor to an existing brand also. In contrast, a brand-new house entertainment facility requires a whole new manufacturing facility. In this latter case, the principle is pretested in the initially phase of product testing and also the product in the second stage. (See the exhibit.) At the conclusion of these principle and also product tests, the profit setup can then be revised to take right into account indevelopment derived from the research study. These brand-new data suggest levels of manufacturing prices and therefore of product acceptability. If a proposed product meets the minimum payout period, it have the right to then go right into extended product usage tests.

Marketing strategy requires establishing objectives, pricing strategies, and circulation methods for a brand-new product. Rough approximates of price arrays may be component of product testing. If your company plans to usage its existing networks of circulation, the channel strategy might be that of determining how to gain your channel to accept the brand-new product. If the strategy has the development of a brand-new channel—such as was forced by the successful Hanes strategy of distributing “L’eggs” hosiery via supermarkets—substantial work-related might be needed to estimate the prices of such a tactic.

Communication strategy has the development of the package, the copy template for advertisements, and the selection of the desired media mix. It is vital to note that the communication setup feeds right into the advance of the marketing mix plans for strategy breakthrough. The approximated cost of the communication plan is input for the final approximated profit plan. The setup is then submitted to management for approval in order to proceed to the test industry phase.

When, then, must a test market be done? The suffer of our specialists says strongly that, as Saint states, “You go into test market under the assumption that you have actually a successful product.”

What Can You Learn?

But when product and communications research study have actually already told you that you have actually a effective product and communication arrangement, why need to you go to the cost of test marketing, adding to the expenses of delayed profits from a effective item?

Our survey suggests that the major purpose of a test sector is to administer, as Newman puts it, a “excellent dress rehearsal for trial and error all of the product elements together, not individually.” Before the test sector, the product and the interaction plan have actually been tested individually. The test sector combines both these elements. In addition, it tests the elements of the arrangement and their combinations in the actual world. It is, Posner says, a “microcosm of what you will be doing and also what will occur nationally.”

A real-world test of the marketing setup will certainly provide estimates of marketing arrangement efficiency, suggestions for boosting the plan’s efficiency, and also a disaster check.

Productivity of the marketing plan

The test sector offers procedures of consumers’ responses to those facets that have actually been pretested—the product, the price, and also the interaction plan. It likewise steps the trade’s acceptance of the product, the strategy, and also the interaction setup. (In the majority of instances, the firm have the right to depend on its experience with the profession to estimate future acceptance.)

Consumer response

By measuring levels of consumer awareness, product trial, repeat purchase, market share, and also sales volume, the test industry offers some indication of the efficiency of the elements of the marketing arrangement. These steps are the basis for making the “go/no-go” decision. Such a decision can be made on the basis of rule-of-thumb—for example, drop the product if the trial rate is less than 60%. The decision is then a financial one, the information from the test sectors having been inputs right into the profit plan.

Test sectors administer much better estimates of consumer response than any pretrial and error. But, as Claycamp emphasizes, “About all you deserve to mean from a test market is the answers to the concerns that you are asking of it. In other words, one hregarding be exceptionally specific about what one desires from a test market. For this factor, they really are designed just for go/no-go decisions.”

Pearboy agrees: “Test marketing can tell you if you have actually a loser, a medium success, or a huge success. It cannot fine-tune a payout arrangement in between a 2 share and also a three share.”

However, Ossip asserts that “we find test markets beneficial in informing us whether we will certainly make our minimum.”

Lavidge sees two factors for a test market: “One reason to test market is to decide how much of the product is likely to offer so that you can decide whether to go nationwide. The various other reason to test sector is to determine just how to market the product.”

Trade response

“How to market” contains the question of profession acceptance—which, in many type of instances, has not been tested in the process of brand-new product development. Saint explains the problem: “Suppose Chesebturbulent came out through an entirely new product in an unfamiliar product category. The Chesebturbulent sales pressure and Chesebunstable as a firm have actually constructed a fine reputation in the health and wellness and beauty-help field. But in this situation you would be taking the Chesebrough salesman and placing him in a new buyer’s office. The soap buyer wouldn’t recognize the salesman. So you would want to check out the capacity of your sales force to offer an unfamiliar product to unacquainted buyers.” Thus acceptance of a new product is considerably dependent on experience and a effective track record.

Experience in the product category enables the researcher to make reputable estimates of profession acceptance. “If you don’t understand what type of distribution your sales pressure is qualified of getting, either you don’t recognize much about your sales world or else they are exceptionally unreputable,” Pearson conhas a tendency.

Experienced researchers estimate that the effect of the added emphasis offered by the sales pressure in the test industry gains a 15% to 17% greater sales level than would certainly be achieved after having actually gone national through the product. Eggert affirms this: “In a test, you obtain more focus, since the sales manager visits the place 2 or 3 times. And just the sheer fact that he visits adds motivation to a product.”

Being first via a brand-new product is incredibly crucial in the grocery-product category, wright here restricted shelf space in a save constrains distribution. When Gillette effectively presented “The Dry Look,” a hair spray for men, numerous other companies tried to cash in on the success by presenting hair sprays of their own. Since hair sprays came in much bigger containers than the majority of hair preparations for guys, more shelf space was required to stock the exact same number of competing brands. And bereason retailers tfinish to devote a addressed amount of shelf space to a certain product category, many type of of the companies through me-as well commodities had challenge getting trade acceptance for duplicated items.

When measuring profession acceptance is not a problem (as is often the case), a marketer might use a controlled keep test, which substantially reduces the time required to run a test industry.

See more: A Market Order Would Be Transacted At The A Lowest, When To Use Limit Orders For Stock Investing

A effective test market deserve to boost the sales force’s ability to obtain distribution in the time of nationwide introduction. A resounding success in, say, Albany kind of is regularly useful to the salesmale seeking trade acceptance in St. Louis. The salesguy is equipped with genuine market results, not in-residence test results or the outcomes of a survey. The only question is whether the results in Albany are applicable to the instance in St. Louis.

How to boost marketing efficiency

As we disputed previously, you need to run a test industry just after extensive pretesting has actually shown that your brand-new product will be a winner. And even though it is useful to gain much better approximates of customer and profession acceptance, some marketers architecture their test markets to provide these better estimates and to provide information that will certainly permit them to improve the performance of the plan. As Schucker says, “Before test marketing, you are convinced at least that the business is there. So the question becomes one of exactly how high you have the right to go, exactly how much leverage with your marketing variables you deserve to use to the service to make it bigger.”

And von Gonten agrees: “I don’t desire to go to test industry via anypoint that I don’t recognize will be a success. And I will certainly usage the test market to derive a method to make my product an even bigger success.”

To use the test market to boost the efficiency of the marketing setup calls for a research design that tests variations in the plan. “Tright here is even more to be learned from test marketing than an estimate of trial and also repeat. Tright here are the results of sampling to be learned. There are likewise the effects of differing levels of promovement to be learned,” Newguy defines.

We carried out a casual survey of 25 marketing research executives attending a seminar on test marketing at the College of North Carolina at Chapel Hill to learn exactly how they recommend using test markets. These are the results: