Last week experienced the Republideserve to presidential nominee Donald Trump nominate his vice presidential candiday in the form of Indiana Governor, Mike Pence; Hillary Clinton will soon announce her very own candidate. Joseph Uscinski writes that the way such vice presidential candidates are selected has come to be significantly less democratic, with the procedure currently in fewer and also fewer hands. He additionally advises that if presidential candidates select a vice president that differs dramatically from them in terms of their plan positions in order to acquire electoral advantage, then this can produce incentives for Congress to remove the Commander-in-Chief.

You are watching: What does it mean to balance the ticket

Eextremely 4 years spectators watch as the presumed American presidential nominees take into consideration and ultimately choose their vice-presidential running mates. Donald Trump announced his selection of Indiana Governor Mike Pence last week; Hillary Clinton is expected to announce her option complying with the Republideserve to convention. The media cover the selection procedures as if they were a parlor game, predicting which party can gain an electdental advantage by choosing which potential running mate.

To increase their possibilities of winning, presidential candidays often pick vice-presidential candidays who differ from them in vital means. Trump’s option of Mike Pence, a social and also establishment conservative, was largely intended to solidify the Republihave the right to base by showing deference to the factivity of the Republihave the right to Party Trump does not appeal to on his own. Hillary Clinton’s potential options remain shrouded, yet it is most likely that the electdental map and existing departments in the Democratic Party will factor right into her choice.

On one hand, “balancing” the ticket with differing individuals provides a normative value: having actually a president and vice president that vary in their positions might deliver larger depiction and also even more well balanced governing. On the various other hand, the winning coalition that made a decision the presidential nominee may not have chosen the nominee’s running-mate; rather, they would certainly have actually preferred a vice-presidential candidate even more equivalent to the nominee. Furthermore, vice-pcitizens tfinish to fall into obscurity after the election, and there is no guarantee that the vice-president will certainly have actually any kind of say in policy.


The selection of vice-presidents has actually fallen right into fewer and fewer hands, making it less democratic. Vice presidents were initially elected by the electoprice, however even more freshly presidential candidays have actually singlehandedly selected their running mates through input just from cshed advisors. This is in opposition to the basic trend towards even more inclusivity in US elections.

The undemocratic nature of the selection procedure has an upside, yet. By giving the alternative of running mate to the presidential candidate, the candiday could choose a running mate who shares their plan views. This would administer secure plan and also a seammuch less transition need to the president all of a sudden leave office. This is vital for democracy: should the country select a president offering a set of policy positions for a four year term, they have to be governed by those policy positions for the term’s duration. An unintended death or removal should not upend majority dominion. But, as soon as presidents and also vice pcitizens differ in considerable ways the nation might inherit a leader espomaking use of plans the nation does not democratically support, and also past this, a perverse collection of political incentives are created.

When a president suddenly leaves office, the vice president deserve to put national policy in line with her very own choices. To recommendation the Godfather, this creates a “Sonny and Vito trouble.” A dissimilarity in between the president and also vice president incentivizes assassicountry as an beneficial means to single-handedly readjust plan, and also it likewise incentivizes Congress to rerelocate a president for political fairly than criminal reasons. Macabre for certain, yet the incentives for fanatics are genuine.

Paradoxically, while electdental incentives proceed to tempt presidential candidays to pick vice pcitizens various from themselves, the supposed electoral benefits are rarely realized. Some researches show that a vice-presidential candidate deserve to swing their home state in specific circumstances; however, many research says that people vote for the names on the top of the ticket with vice-presidential candidates having little impact on general election outcomes.

As we think around Donald Trump’s choice of Mike Pence, or of Hillary’s forthcoming choice, we have to relocate away from the electdental considerations. Instead, we should emphasis even more on the prospect of succession. Unmeant succession is not uncommon: nine or one fifth of all US Poccupants flourished because of the fatality of the sitting president. Gerald Ford gone into the White Housage after Richard Nixon’s resigcountry. These ten poccupants served a complete of forty-two years. Therefore, we should encourage candidays to pick running mates that have the right to encertain stcapability, continuity, and autonomous outcomes for the full four years of the presidential term.

This article summarizes arguments in “Smith (and Jones) Go to Washington: Democracy and Vice-Presidential Selection” publimelted in PS: Political Science & Politics.

Please review our comments plan prior to commenting.  

Note: This short article provides the views of the writer, and also not the place of USAPP – Amerihave the right to Politics and also Policy, nor the London School of Economics.

See more: Why Should Silver Chloride Be Protected From Light ? Experiment 8

Shortened URL for this post: http://little


About the author

Joseph E. Uscinski College of MiamiJoseph E. Uscinski is Associate Professor of Political Science at College of Miami College of Arts & Sciences and coauthor of Amerideserve to Conspiracy Theories (Oxford College Press, 2014).